mirror of
https://github.com/OrcaSlicer/OrcaSlicer.git
synced 2026-10-10 17:21:10 +00:00
Clifford GarwoodandClaude Opus 4.7
ee757dac20
Self-review found two weaknesses in the preceding test commits:
1) The equal-size [Variant] scenario claimed to distinguish the truncation
guard's `cur > target` predicate from a regression to `cur >= target`,
but both paths yield identical child values in practice: when
extruder_variant names match, set_with_restore's variant_index is fully
populated (no -1 slots) and the merge path restores every position from
backup — producing the same {1.5, 2.5} output as the skip path. The
test passes in both guard states.
Rewritten to use mismatched variant names between child and parent.
variant_index then has -1 slots, and set_with_restore overwrites those
positions with parent values. Now the merge path yields {0.8, 0.8} and
the skip path yields {1.5, 2.5} — observably different. Verified:
- `cur > target` (correct): 4 scenarios pass, 15 assertions
- `cur >= target` (regressed): equal-size scenario fails with
"1.5 is within 0.000000001 of 0.80000000000000004"
- Guard removed entirely: child>parent + stride=2 both fail with
truncation ("1 == 2" / "2 == 4")
2) The [3mf][IMEX] round-trip only covered a single plate. A plate-
indexing regression (IMEX metadata landing on the wrong plate, or
bleeding across plates on reload) would not have been caught.
Added a multi-plate scenario: two plates with distinct mode and
head-filament-map values. Asserts both land on their respective
destination plates after reload. Load-bearing verified:
- With IMEX serialization intact: 3 scenarios pass, 45 assertions
- With IMEX serialization disabled: positive + multi-plate fail
(both "nullptr != nullptr"); primary-mode passes (expects nullptr)
- With primary-mode short-circuit removed: primary-mode scenario
fails ("0x... == nullptr") because primary modes now serialize
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>