mirror of
https://github.com/OrcaSlicer/OrcaSlicer.git
synced 2026-09-27 02:41:17 +00:00
Tommaso BianchiandClaude Opus 5
b4d6abc57a
Tommaso's decision (snaporca-x0kd): face orientation is hardwired perception -- a toddler reads
a face's roll and verse with no instruction -- so the connector is a face by default and the
conventional disc + roll quadrant stays, selectable, for users who expect it.
Preferences > Control > Camera > "Draw mate connectors as a face", default ON, key
design_connector_face_glyph. Read every frame rather than latched, so toggling takes effect on
the next repaint -- a look you cannot A/B without restarting will not get compared. Verified on
the rig: unchecking it switches the viewport to the disc live, no restart.
WHY A RELIEF AND NOT A DRAWING. A flat face in the connector's plane foreshortens by
sin(elevation) and collapses at a grazing view exactly like the quadrant it replaces -- measured,
the quadrant falls 89 -> 20 -> 3 -> 0 lit pixels from 47 degrees to edge-on. The relief does not:
its silhouette carries the information. So the glyph is a small shaded solid, painter-sorted,
lambert-shaded against a light fixed in CAMERA space so orbiting does not swing the shading.
THE MUZZLE, AND THE MISTAKE THAT NEARLY LOST IT. It is the only feature standing along +Z, so it
says which way the connector points and it is all that survives edge-on. Two errors on the way:
1. I built its footprint from height*tan(draft) and got a needle. The real base OVERHANGS the
crest at both ends (0.062 nose, 0.034 tail) and that overhang is what makes it a wedge. Base
now lifted straight off the mesh.
2. Worse, I chased fidelity. Scaled honestly the ridge is 11.3 mm on an 83.3 mm face -- 13.6 %
of the width -- and at 22-48 px that is a scratch. Tommaso looked at it and could not find
the muzzle at all, which is the only test that counts. A glyph is a symbol, not a scale
model, so it now gets two deliberate exaggerations, and COLOUR does most of the work:
muzzle share of lit pixels at 90/16/6 deg -- body tone 14.8/11.3/17.5 %, accent gold
18.3/19.2/23.9 %, accent gold at 1.8x width 23.5/25.2/31.2 %.
The accent is the same gold the disc spends on its roll quadrant, so it stays this tab's "here
is the direction that matters" colour. Polarity is still on the Z arrow's head; nothing collides.
A connector whose ROLL COULD NOT BE DERIVED keeps the disc treatment whatever the preference says.
A face asserts a definite orientation, and asserting one for a roll that was never derived is the
same confident lie that got billboarding rejected.
Geometry is emitted from the part by docs/design/mate-connectors/emit_glyph_table.py, not
hand-drawn, so glyph and printed connector cannot drift: 12-vertex outline, two eyes, chin bar,
cheek dot, and the snout wedge. Crest 29.0 mm / 6.58 mm drop / 13.1 deg against the review's
28.3 / 6.61 / 13.1 on the B-rep.
Also fixes extract_outline.py, which walked w.Edges: OCC returns them in storage order, not ring
order, ignoring per-edge orientation, so the outline was scrambled -- 45 points and perimeter
6.380 where a clean ring gives 31 and 3.335. Every measurement in the design notes was re-run.
The correction reversed one earlier finding: handedness does NOT read on its own (5.4/8.0/9.1 %
different from its mirror, not the 32-35 % the scrambled ring produced), so the cheek dot is
required rather than merely nice.
RIG-VERIFIED on Xvfb :12 against a 60x40x10 box with a face+edge connector: the face renders with
both eyes, ears, chin bar, cheek dot and a gold muzzle standing proud; the Z arrow degenerates to
its ring when viewed down the axis; and the preference switches to the disc live.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 line
1.8 KiB
JSON
1 line
1.8 KiB
JSON
{"outer": [[26.711, -55.263], [42.071, -7.071], [35.0, -0.0], [-32.575, 0.0], [-33.717, -0.112], [-34.815, -0.446], [-35.828, -0.987], [-36.715, -1.715], [-39.55, -4.55], [-40.35, -5.547], [-40.914, -6.694], [-41.216, -7.937], [-41.241, -9.215], [-40.988, -10.468], [-26.711, -55.263], [-28.828, -57.312], [-29.64, -58.335], [-30.159, -59.532], [-30.35, -60.823], [-30.201, -62.12], [-29.721, -63.334], [-28.944, -64.382], [-27.718, -65.649], [-27.075, -66.035], [-26.325, -66.047], [-25.67, -65.683], [-20.613, -60.789], [20.613, -60.789], [26.711, -66.69], [32.421, -60.789], [26.711, -55.263]], "holes": [{"pts": [[19.052, -18.464], [16.474, -9.14], [-0.0, -9.104], [-21.926, -9.104], [-21.926, -3.535], [22.308, -3.535], [19.052, -18.464]], "cx": 4.719, "cz": -10.192, "d": 44.234}, {"pts": [[-11.493, -48.01], [-11.676, -49.341], [-12.211, -50.574], [-13.06, -51.617], [-14.158, -52.392], [-15.424, -52.842], [-16.765, -52.934], [-18.081, -52.66], [-19.274, -52.042], [-20.257, -51.124], [-20.955, -49.976], [-21.318, -48.682], [-21.318, -47.337], [-20.955, -46.043], [-20.257, -44.895], [-19.274, -43.977], [-18.081, -43.359], [-16.765, -43.085], [-15.424, -43.177], [-14.158, -43.627], [-13.06, -44.402], [-12.211, -45.445], [-11.676, -46.678], [-11.493, -48.01]], "cx": -16.223, "cz": -48.01, "d": 9.825}, {"pts": [[21.364, -48.01], [21.181, -49.341], [20.645, -50.574], [19.797, -51.617], [18.699, -52.392], [17.432, -52.842], [16.091, -52.934], [14.775, -52.66], [13.582, -52.042], [12.6, -51.124], [11.901, -49.976], [11.539, -48.682], [11.539, -47.337], [11.901, -46.043], [12.6, -44.895], [13.582, -43.977], [14.775, -43.359], [16.091, -43.085], [17.432, -43.177], [18.699, -43.627], [19.797, -44.402], [20.645, -45.445], [21.181, -46.678], [21.364, -48.01]], "cx": 16.634, "cz": -48.01, "d": 9.825}]} |