The charter had accessibility only in the assistive sense — keyboard, contrast,
colour, targets — and said nothing about who can get through the door in the
first place. That was the larger omission. The premise of an OSS CAD tool is
that a kid on a school laptop, with no licence, no account, no fast machine and
nobody to teach them, can open it and make a real thing; a tool that only the
equipped can run reaches people who were already going to design something.
So the fourteen-year-old is now the FIRST of three audiences, ahead of the maker
and the mechanical designer, with an explicit rule that when audiences conflict
the earlier one wins unless someone writes down why not.
L11 states the floor: runs completely on a low-end laptop with integrated
graphics at 1366x768, offline, no account, and no capability withheld behind a
tier, a plugin or a cloud service. Section 6 splits into 6.1 reach and 6.2 the
assistive floor: the reference machine, the small screen as the layout target
rather than the stretch case, files that belong to the user, learnable with no
documentation, plain language at the entry tier, and exploration that is never
punished — undo reaches everything, nothing asks the user to be sure.
Consequences elsewhere: the screen budget is set by the smallest screen we
serve, not the reviewer's monitor; the PR gate gains a reach question; B6 joins
the benchmark (the inner loop on the reference machine, offline, fresh install)
and every task is measured there rather than on a workstation. The side-panel
debt now fails L11 as well as L1 — on that screen the cards leave the model a
strip.
One role addition: the absent audience needs a seat. The kid cannot file an
issue, so someone owns B5/B6 and the group watches real first-timers quarterly.
Approachability is the one thing here that cannot be argued from principle.
snaporca-2is.
The doctrine is shared but the document is not: each fork's copy now speaks
about its own product only, so it reads as that project's own charter rather
than as a note about a sibling repository. This is a deliberate divergence —
the two copies must NOT be reconciled by a parity sweep. The CAD sources stay
byte-identical; only this doc branches.
snaporca-2is.
The call with SoftFever settled that Orca-CAD is one of the branches to be
implemented and that a design+dev group forms around it. A group without a
written doctrine reviews by taste, and a CAD reviewed by taste becomes
FreeCAD one locally-reasonable side panel at a time.
So the doctrine is written first, as something a reviewer can FAIL a pull
request against: ten laws each with its own test, the interaction grammar
they compose into, the accessibility floor as a merge requirement, and a
ten-question gate answered in every UI pull request.
The position is Shapr3D's interaction economy, not its feature list —
direct, gestural, almost no chrome, depth revealed by what you touch. Depth
for mechanical designers arrives as progressive disclosure of tools that
never move, in three tiers, non-modal, with assemblies and exploded views
obeying the same point-then-act grammar as a beginner's extrude.
The one thing neither Shapr3D nor FreeCAD has is that we live inside a
slicer: plate, nozzle, material and build volume are known at design time,
so print-domain failures are warnings on the geometry, not a report.
Section 10 is an honest inventory: what already complies, and the six
things that violate the laws today, none of them defended. The appendix
keeps the anti-patterns we have already paid for, because each one is
cheap to reintroduce.
snaporca-2is.
* Add wxInspector dep
* Initial intergration of wxInspector
* docs: add wxInspector plugins design spec
Design spec for two wxInspector plugins (DPIAware + CustomWidgets) that expose
OrcaSlicer's custom control properties in the inspector property grid.
Covers: DPIAware scale-factor properties, Button, CheckBox, TextInput,
SwitchButton, ProgressBar, Label, and LabeledStaticBox.
* docs: add wxInspector plugins implementation plan
6-task plan covering: source changes to existing widget headers,
DPIAwarePlugin, CustomWidgetsPlugin, registration helper,
MainFrame/CMake wiring, and build verification.
* feat: add getters/setters for wxInspector plugin access
Add minimal public accessors to DPIAware (set_scale_factor,
set_prev_scale_factor, set_em_unit, force_rescale), Button
(GetStyle, GetType, IsSelected), CheckBox (IsHalfChecked),
TextInput (GetCornerRadius), and LabeledStaticBox
(GetCornerRadius, GetBorderWidth, GetBorderColor, GetScale).
* feat: add wxInspector plugin registration helper
Add RegisterOrcaInspectorPlugins() inline function that creates
and registers the DPIAwarePlugin and CustomWidgetsPlugin as
static instances (matching wxInspector's built-in pattern).
* feat: add DPIAware wxInspector plugin
Exposes DPI scaling properties (scale_factor, prev_scale_factor,
em_unit, normal_font, force_rescale) on DPIFrame and DPIDialog
widgets. Uses dynamic_cast for detection and a template helper
to capture the correct static type for lambda accessors.
* feat: add OrcaCustomWidgets wxInspector plugin
Exposes Orca-specific properties on 7 widget types:
- Button: Style, Type, Selected
- CheckBox: Half Checked
- TextInput: Label, Text Value, Corner Radius
- SwitchButton: Value
- ProgressBar: Proportion, Show Number
- Label: Is Hyperlink, Font Point Size
- LabeledStaticBox: Corner Radius, Border Width, Border Color, Scale
Each widget type uses dynamic_cast for safe detection.
* feat: wire wxInspector plugins into MainFrame and build
Call RegisterOrcaInspectorPlugins() in MainFrame constructor after
SetupInspectorAccelerator(). Add all 5 plugin source files to
SLIC3R_GUI_SOURCES in CMakeLists.txt.
* fix: move plugin registration to GUI_App::on_init_inner
Register plugins once in app init rather than in MainFrame
constructor, which may be recreated during the application
lifetime.
* fix: include plugin headers in Registration.hpp for complete types
Static locals require complete type. Include DPIAwarePlugin.hpp and
CustomWidgetsPlugin.hpp instead of forward-declaring. Also remove
unused include from MainFrame.cpp (registration moved to GUI_App).
* fix: qualify DPIFrame/DPIDialog with Slic3r::GUI namespace
* Make DPIDialog inspectable. For other dialogs, we will add them if necessary later.
* docs: add spec for moving wxInspectable into DPIAware template
Move wxInspector::wxInspectable base class from DPIDialog and MainFrame
into the common DPIAware<P> template, making all DPIAware widgets
automatically visible in the inspector tree.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* docs: add implementation plan for moving wxInspectable into DPIAware
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* docs: update spec/plan — move SetupInspectorAccelerator into DPIAware too
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* refactor: move wxInspectable and SetupInspectorAccelerator into DPIAware
DPIAware<P> now inherits wxInspector::wxInspectable and calls
SetupInspectorAccelerator in its constructor, making all DPIAware
widgets automatically appear in the inspector tree with the
Ctrl+Shift+I shortcut. DPIDialog now uses 'using' to inherit the
constructor. Remove redundant wxInspectable inheritance and
SetupInspectorAccelerator calls from DPIDialog and MainFrame.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix: use LB_HYPERLINK constant instead of magic number 0x0020
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* Clean up
* Fix Linux build
* Don't build wxInspector sample
* Use shallow clone
* Try fix flatpak build
* Attempt to fix build again
* Fix build failure caused by https://github.com/wxWidgets/wxWidgets/commit/436c16135ec7ddf580f44624bf74c592aae43b66
* wxWidgets build only download required submodules
* This should fix build on Windows on ARM
* Enable PIC
* Disable layout inspector by default for public release
* Use wxInspector 1.0.0 release
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
docs/design_tab_upstream_portability.md explains the subsystem to a
maintainer; nothing explained it to a user. This is that: what the tab is,
how to get a first solid out of it, every tool grouped the way the toolbar
groups them, and the keyboard shortcuts read out of the source rather than
remembered.
The limitations section is deliberate. Rib needing a sketch with an explicit
open line, Surface Loft and Surface Fill having no hands-on verification, mates
composing transforms instead of solving simultaneously, move-face and
replace-face being absent, and the two quarantined kernel tests are all things
a user would otherwise discover by hitting them.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Maintainers will ask what the Design tab costs before they will look at the
diff, so measure it rather than assert it.
The headline correction: the OCCT delta is THREE toolkits, not two. The
comment in deps/OCCT/OCCT.cmake claimed "TKFillet + TKOffset (3.77 MiB,
Windows only)". Walking OCCT's own adm/MODULES and each toolkit's EXTERNLIB
shows ModelingAlgorithms holds twelve toolkits, that eight of them are built
either way because DataExchange (the STEP path upstream already ships) depends
on them, and that the true delta is TKFeat, TKFillet, TKOffset and TKXMesh —
of which TKXMesh is never produced. So three archives are built: 7.40, 5.38
and 4.42 MiB.
TKFeat is the interesting one. Nothing in the Design tab references it and it
is absent from the TKFillet/TKOffset dependency closure, so it is built for
nothing — OCCT's module flag is all-or-nothing per module. On static-link
platforms that is build time and zero shipped bytes.
Two numbers are deliberately absent, marked as absent, and not approximated:
the Windows DLL delta needs a Windows build (snaporca-gix), and a clean-build
time delta needs the deps prefix built twice on one machine. The old 3.77 MiB
figure is withdrawn rather than reused — it covered two of the three toolkits.
Also recorded: the vendored solver is 9,339 lines under GPLv3 with its LICENSE
preserved, which combines into this AGPLv3 fork without difficulty (AGPLv3
§13), and it is live code driving every sketch constraint — not a carried
corpse.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Enumerated from the source rather than from recollection: CadFeatureType and
add_* in CadDocument.hpp, Tool in DesignPanel.hpp, Mode in
DesignSketchTool.hpp, SketchConstraintType + SketchEntity::Type in
SketchEngine.hpp, and the JSON-RPC dispatch in McpControl.cpp.
Findings worth stating up front:
- The 2D sketcher is at or near Onshape parity -- 19 constraints, every entity
type including B-splines and elliptical arcs, trim/extend/offset/mirror and
both array kinds. Very little is missing there.
- The gaps are all breadth beyond sketching: assemblies/mates, surface
modelling, sheet metal, drawings, and variables/configurations.
- The most defensible criticism is the absence of variables and expressions.
Every dimension is a literal double, so the feature tree is parametric in
structure but not in value -- "change one number and the model updates" is
only half delivered. It is also the cheapest Tier 1 item to close.
The doc separates platform capabilities (version control, FeatureScript, FEA,
rendering, cloud PDM) into their own tier rather than counting them as missing
tools: that is Onshape-the-platform, not Onshape-the-modeller, and holding a
slicer tab to it would not be a fair comparison.
One entry is a correctness gap rather than a missing feature: move/rotate body
(m_body_xform) is display-only and never enters the B-rep, so a moved body
exports and booleans at its original position while the viewport shows it
moved.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BVzKmX6Y1aEteit1HTXG4Q
The 2026-06-21 assessment was written before the persistence work landed and
got two load-bearing facts wrong. Both are corrected here against the branch
itself rather than from recollection:
1. It called OCCT "a dependency mainline OrcaSlicer has never carried" and
built its whole conclusion on that. False: deps/OCCT/ exists at the
merge-base, and upstream already links it from Format/STEP.cpp,
Format/svg.cpp and Shape/TextShape.cpp. The real dependency diff is one
line -- BUILD_MODULE_ModelingAlgorithms OFF -> ON -- costing a measured
3.77 MiB of Windows DLLs (TKFillet + TKOffset; TKBool already arrives
transitively via DataExchange).
2. It described the vendored SolveSpace solver as LGPL. False:
src/libslic3r/slvs/LICENSE is GPL-3.0. Harmless for us, but a licence
must not be misstated in a document aimed at upstream.
It also claimed no changes to Model, which stopped being true when 3MF
recipe persistence added a std::string there.
The rewrite replaces prose estimates with counted figures: 138 new files,
23 modified upstream files at +457/-75, nothing deleted, 99.3 % of the diff
in new files. That reframes the ask from "adopt a CAD kernel" to "widen a
build flag you already carry", which is the argument that actually has a
chance upstream.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BVzKmX6Y1aEteit1HTXG4Q
Tommaso Bianchi