mirror of
https://github.com/OrcaSlicer/OrcaSlicer.git
synced 2026-10-15 03:41:28 +00:00
Merge branch 'main' into feat/texdisp-tooltip-media
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,135 @@
|
||||
# Mesh repair — High Level Design
|
||||
|
||||
## Purpose and scope
|
||||
|
||||
Mesh repair turns a broken triangle mesh into closed, outward oriented shells that bound a solid, so that the
|
||||
mesh slices predictably and the other mesh tools (booleans, cut, painting) get valid input. It runs on demand:
|
||||
the *Fix Model* command of the context menu of an object or part and of the warning icon in the object list, *Fix
|
||||
All* and *Fix All Plates* in the context menu of a plate, the prompt the Cut tool shows when a cut leaves open edges,
|
||||
the *Repair and import* choice of texture import, and the `--repair` option of the command line. It is built on CGAL
|
||||
and is the only repair the application has, on every platform.
|
||||
|
||||
`repair_mesh()` in `src/libslic3r/MeshRepair.cpp` does the work on one `TriangleMesh`, and `ModelVolume::repair()`
|
||||
applies it to a part: it replaces the mesh only when the repair changed it, and remaps or drops the painting of a
|
||||
replaced mesh. The GUI side, `fix_model_with_cgal_gui()` in `src/slic3r/Utils/FixModelByCgal.cpp`, runs it on a
|
||||
worker thread for each volume of an object, or for one volume, behind a progress dialog. `repair_mesh()` reports its
|
||||
progress between stages through a callback, which cancels the repair by throwing.
|
||||
|
||||
## What the repaired mesh is
|
||||
|
||||
The repair keeps what the slicer would print from the input. The slicer fills a layer where the winding number of
|
||||
the input surface is not zero (`MeshSlicingParams::SlicingMode::Regular` uses Clipper's nonzero fill rule), so:
|
||||
|
||||
- Shells crossing each other print as their union. The repair keeps them as separate shells, as the parts of an
|
||||
object are kept, and makes each of them an outward oriented solid.
|
||||
- A shell inside a solid that is oriented like it adds nothing, and the repair removes it.
|
||||
- A shell inside a solid that is oriented inward is a cavity, and stays one.
|
||||
- A whole mesh turned inside out prints as a solid, and the repair turns it outward.
|
||||
|
||||
On top of that, it closes holes and cracks, gives inconsistently oriented triangles the orientation of their
|
||||
neighbours, drops degenerate, duplicate and stray flat geometry, and removes small self-intersections inside a shell,
|
||||
such as slivers and folds. Where none of this applies, it reports the mesh as unmodified and the caller keeps the
|
||||
original mesh, its painting and its object id.
|
||||
|
||||
A volume is repaired in place and is never split into several parts: splitting by connectivity would turn a cavity
|
||||
into a separate solid part and fill it. Each solid of the result is a shell of its own, so *Split to parts* still
|
||||
separates them. Open pieces of the input whose borders meet exactly, which are pieces of one surface rather than
|
||||
solids, come out as the one shell they form.
|
||||
|
||||
## Pipeline
|
||||
|
||||
The input is treated as a triangle soup. Every stage after the first only runs on what the previous ones could
|
||||
not settle, so a valid mesh passes through quickly.
|
||||
|
||||
### Valid parts first
|
||||
|
||||
Parts of the input that are connected by vertex indices and are already closed, consistently oriented 2-manifolds
|
||||
skip the soup stages and go straight to the shell stages. Merging their points with coincident points of other
|
||||
parts would only make non-manifold junctions out of solids that touch, for example parts of an assembly exported
|
||||
together or voxels written as separate cubes.
|
||||
|
||||
### Soup clean-up
|
||||
|
||||
The rest of the soup has its coincident points merged. Triangles with repeated corners are dropped. Coincident
|
||||
triangles of opposite orientation are a wall between two solids touching face to face, so they cancel in pairs;
|
||||
of the remaining copies of a triangle one is kept. A connected region that would vanish entirely through
|
||||
cancelling is a two-sided export instead (every face written in both orientations), and keeps one copy of each
|
||||
triangle.
|
||||
|
||||
Open edges then get their vertices welded within a tolerance of 1e-4 of the bounding box diagonal, which closes the
|
||||
cracks some exporters leave between triangles that should share corners. A vertex is never welded further than a
|
||||
quarter of its shortest edge, so welding cannot collapse fine detail. A soup that stays mostly open after welding has
|
||||
cracks wider than that tolerance, and is welded again with ten and then a hundred times the tolerance.
|
||||
|
||||
### Work units
|
||||
|
||||
The soup is cut into units repaired independently and in parallel: its connected parts, except that open parts whose
|
||||
bounding boxes touch share a unit, so that cracks and T-junctions between separately exported patches still close.
|
||||
|
||||
### Building the mesh
|
||||
|
||||
A unit whose edges are each shared by at most two triangles, running in opposite directions, and whose vertices each
|
||||
have a single fan of triangles, becomes a `Surface_mesh` directly. Any other unit is oriented first. Triangles are
|
||||
flipped so that neighbours across an edge shared by two of them agree, each part keeping the orientation the
|
||||
majority of its area had, which keeps inward oriented cavities inward. Edges where that is impossible or that more
|
||||
than two triangles share are cut, and each fan of triangles around a vertex gets its own copy of the vertex. If that
|
||||
still leaves an invalid mesh, CGAL's `orient_polygon_soup()` orients the unit instead, and the parts it flipped
|
||||
against their majority are reversed back. The linear pass exists because `orient_polygon_soup()` is several times
|
||||
slower on large soups that need only a few fixes.
|
||||
|
||||
### Closing
|
||||
|
||||
Compatible borders are stitched, parts that can be stitched once reversed are merged, and borders still open are
|
||||
snapped onto each other within the weld tolerance, which closes T-junctions. Exactly degenerate faces are removed.
|
||||
|
||||
Holes are filled last. Planar border loops that face each other in one plane, one inside the other, bound a single
|
||||
region, such as a missing annulus at the end of a tube or a cap with features standing on it. Such a group is
|
||||
triangulated at once with a 2D constrained Delaunay triangulation that fills only the faces at odd nesting depth,
|
||||
so the openings inside the region stay open. The patch is used only if it closes every loop with the orientation
|
||||
of the triangles around it. Every other loop is filled on its own with `triangulate_hole()`, which uses a 2D
|
||||
constrained Delaunay triangulation when the loop is planar. Otherwise it searches the best triangulation among all
|
||||
triangles over the loop for loops of up to 100 edges, and among the triangles of a 3D Delaunay triangulation for
|
||||
longer ones, as the full search is cubic in the length of the loop. Beyond 200 edges the full search is not even
|
||||
used as a fallback, and a fan around the loop's centroid closes a loop nothing else could.
|
||||
|
||||
The closed unit is split into its shells. The largest stays in place and the others are copied out, as converting
|
||||
the whole mesh again costs seconds on large models.
|
||||
|
||||
### Shells
|
||||
|
||||
The shells of all units, together with the valid parts set aside at the start, are handled independently and in
|
||||
parallel. Shells enclosing no volume, which hole filling makes out of stray flat patches, are dropped.
|
||||
|
||||
Self-intersections inside a shell are removed locally with `experimental::remove_self_intersections()`, which
|
||||
remeshes the region around them. It is used only for local defects: a shell whose intersections involve more than
|
||||
5 % of its faces is left as it is, and a result that changes the enclosed volume by more than 0.1 % is undone. On
|
||||
heavily overlapping ornamental models the remeshing otherwise cuts parts down to slivers, while on genuine defects
|
||||
it changes the volume by thousandths of a percent. Overlaps left in place slice correctly. Remeshing can cut
|
||||
small pieces off a shell, so a shell it changed is split again and its pieces enclosing no volume are dropped.
|
||||
|
||||
Shells crossing others are found through their bounding boxes and an AABB tree per shell, and are made outward
|
||||
oriented solids. For every other shell the winding number just outside it is summed from the orientation of the
|
||||
shells containing it, tested from a point on its largest face. The shell bounds the solid only if the winding
|
||||
number is zero on exactly one of its sides; it is then oriented so that the solid is inside, or dropped otherwise.
|
||||
|
||||
Crossing shells are not united. Slicing unites them anyway, uniting them exactly costs tens of seconds on models
|
||||
made of many overlapping pieces, and it would fuse parts that *Split to parts* should keep apart.
|
||||
|
||||
## Robustness
|
||||
|
||||
The repair avoids `experimental::autorefine_and_remove_self_intersections()` and corefinement, which can crash on
|
||||
messy input, and uses only steps whose failures it can detect. A step that fails keeps its input. CGAL precondition
|
||||
failures surface as `repair_mesh()` returning false with the message as the error. The output is written in float,
|
||||
as every mesh in the application is.
|
||||
|
||||
The result does not depend on thread scheduling. `libslic3r_cgal` is built with `CGAL_LINKED_WITH_TBB`. Units and
|
||||
shells are processed in parallel, but each on its own data, and their results are gathered in a fixed order;
|
||||
sorts compare complete keys, and the detected self-intersections are put in order before they are used. Snapping
|
||||
stays sequential, as its parallel version gives different results from run to run. Holes are filled with the full
|
||||
search wherever it is affordable, because the search among Delaunay triangles can choose between equally good fills
|
||||
differently from run to run, so only non-planar holes of more than 100 edges may still vary. On some inputs
|
||||
`experimental::remove_self_intersections()` itself places a few vertices differently from run to run.
|
||||
|
||||
## Verification
|
||||
|
||||
`tests/libslic3r/test_mesh_repair.cpp` covers each kind of defect above on small meshes with known volumes.
|
||||
@@ -15,8 +15,9 @@ Outlines of centerlines that cross each other overlap at every crossing, which
|
||||
over-extrudes the wall intersections. The line-crossing patterns Grid,
|
||||
Triangles, Tri-hexagon and Cubic therefore build centerlines that never cross
|
||||
(`FillRectilinear::fill_surface_trapezoidal()`), and so do Adaptive Cubic and
|
||||
Support Cubic (`FillAdaptive`); the other patterns outline their usual
|
||||
centerlines.
|
||||
Support Cubic (`FillAdaptive`). 3D Honeycomb skips `multiline_fill()` and draws
|
||||
its N lines itself as parallel copies of each wave, which never cross
|
||||
(`Fill3DHoneycomb`). The other patterns outline their usual centerlines.
|
||||
|
||||
## Non-crossing centerlines
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
+38
-22
@@ -82,9 +82,7 @@ there.
|
||||
strong point is placed, no later strong modifier and no weak modifier is
|
||||
processed for that perimeter.
|
||||
- **Weak:** every weak modifier applies. They are applied from the lowest
|
||||
priority to the highest, so the highest one overwrites overlapping zones. A
|
||||
Blocked modifier that fully contains a perimeter is the exception: it is
|
||||
skipped there (see [Full containment](#full-containment)).
|
||||
priority to the highest, so the highest one overwrites overlapping zones.
|
||||
|
||||
A strong modifier without a usable segment, even one whose fragments were all
|
||||
discarded, passes the turn to the next one.
|
||||
@@ -232,20 +230,23 @@ begin and end positions on the source contour.
|
||||
### Full containment
|
||||
|
||||
A modifier that covers the whole perimeter has no boundaries on it. The policy
|
||||
follows seam painting, where painting a whole perimeter green is a meaningful
|
||||
choice and forbidding the seam all round is not:
|
||||
follows seam painting, where a whole perimeter can be painted in either color:
|
||||
|
||||
- **Seam Enforced** types the whole perimeter, like a perimeter painted green all
|
||||
round, with subdivision applied as described under [Weak modifiers](#weak-modifiers).
|
||||
- **Seam Neutral** types the whole perimeter Neutral, like an unmarked perimeter,
|
||||
clearing painting and lower zones.
|
||||
- **Seam Blocked** is skipped for the perimeter, with the full-containment
|
||||
warning. The seam cannot avoid the whole perimeter, so the modifier does not
|
||||
override anything below it: lower zones and painting stay in effect.
|
||||
- **Seam Center, Left and Right** are skipped with the same warning: there is no
|
||||
intersection to place the point on.
|
||||
- **Seam Blocked** types the whole perimeter Blocked, like a perimeter painted
|
||||
red all round, overriding painting and lower zones. The seam cannot avoid such
|
||||
a perimeter: the seam placer compares Blocked candidates with each other like
|
||||
Neutral ones, so the seam is placed as on an unmarked perimeter. If the
|
||||
perimeter stays Blocked after all weak zones, it is reported in the user
|
||||
warning (see [Diagnostics and warnings](#diagnostics-and-warnings)), so the
|
||||
user can check the modifier.
|
||||
- **Seam Center, Left and Right** are skipped with the full-containment warning:
|
||||
there is no intersection to place the point on.
|
||||
|
||||
Enforced and Neutral take part in the usual priority order (see
|
||||
Enforced, Neutral and Blocked take part in the usual priority order (see
|
||||
[Weak modifiers](#weak-modifiers)).
|
||||
|
||||
The perimeter is fully contained when the united intervals cover every source
|
||||
@@ -311,9 +312,9 @@ into every perimeter that has a strong seam.
|
||||
`collect_weak_modifier_segments()` extracts the segments of every weak modifier
|
||||
before the polygon is modified, so all positions refer to the same contour. Each
|
||||
segment becomes a zone with a type and two boundaries, kept in application
|
||||
order, lowest priority first. Full containment of an Enforced or Neutral
|
||||
modifier becomes a whole-perimeter zone at its place in that order: it has no
|
||||
boundaries and takes part in no insertion or helper step below. The boundaries
|
||||
order, lowest priority first. Full containment of a weak modifier becomes a
|
||||
whole-perimeter zone at its place in that order: it has no boundaries and takes
|
||||
part in no insertion or helper step below. The boundaries
|
||||
carry their positions on the source contour; these remain as provenance after
|
||||
insertion and are not indices into the modified polygon.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -384,9 +385,10 @@ G-code export issues it as one non-critical warning with the ID
|
||||
`SlicingPreciseSeamWarning`. It is a single line, "Precise Seam: <causes>. Seam
|
||||
placement may differ from expected.", because the export warnings dialog shows
|
||||
only the first line of each warning. Repeated warning events replace the
|
||||
notification instead of appending to it. Except for the "had no effect" cause,
|
||||
the causes name the modifier types involved, as the menu names them, in menu
|
||||
order and each type once, for example "(Seam Left, Seam Enforced)".
|
||||
notification instead of appending to it. Except for the "covers an entire
|
||||
perimeter" and "had no effect" causes, the causes name the modifier types
|
||||
involved, as the menu names them, in menu order and each type once, for example
|
||||
"(Seam Left, Seam Enforced)".
|
||||
The causes are:
|
||||
|
||||
- **failed to process some intersections (types):** at least one fragment was
|
||||
@@ -395,8 +397,18 @@ The causes are:
|
||||
a Seam Center, Left or Right modifier had more than one segment on a
|
||||
perimeter (see [Strong modifiers](#strong-modifiers)).
|
||||
- **a perimeter is fully inside a modifier, the modifier was not applied to it
|
||||
(types):** a Seam Center, Left, Right or Blocked modifier was skipped for a
|
||||
(types):** a Seam Center, Left or Right modifier was skipped for a
|
||||
perimeter (see [Full containment](#full-containment)).
|
||||
- **Seam Blocked modifier "<name>" of "<object>" covers an entire perimeter:**
|
||||
a Seam Blocked modifier covered a whole perimeter (see
|
||||
[Full containment](#full-containment)). Only perimeters whose candidates are
|
||||
all Blocked after all weak zones contribute to this warning, and only through
|
||||
the zone in effect there: `apply_weak_modifiers_to_perimeter()` checks the
|
||||
final types and flags the modifier of the highest whole-perimeter zone when it
|
||||
is Blocked. A lower whole zone is overwritten by it and is not reported. Only
|
||||
the first flagged modifier in print and volume order is named, followed by
|
||||
"(N in total)" when there are several. The type name reuses the menu's
|
||||
translation.
|
||||
- **modifier "<name>" of "<object>" had no effect on the seam (it might not reach
|
||||
the centerline of the printed perimeter):** a modifier was evaluated on at
|
||||
least one perimeter and never gave a segment, full containment or a discarded
|
||||
@@ -420,6 +432,8 @@ The log records the following diagnostic markers:
|
||||
- `[PreciseSeamNoEffect]` for every modifier of the "had no effect" cause, with
|
||||
the object and modifier names. Unlike the user warning, the log lists all of
|
||||
them.
|
||||
- `[PreciseSeamFullyBlocked]` for every modifier of the "covers an entire
|
||||
perimeter" cause, listed the same way.
|
||||
|
||||
Failures and recoveries are counted separately. The first 10 of each per
|
||||
`init()` call are logged in detail, in parallel processing order; if a limit is
|
||||
@@ -563,12 +577,14 @@ last modifier would.
|
||||
priorities, weak boundaries that coincide or share an edge, enforced
|
||||
subdivision, whole-perimeter weak zones with painting and priorities, weak
|
||||
zones over painting's oversampled candidates, the warning type masks, usage
|
||||
tracking for the "had no effect" warning, volume sorting of strong and weak
|
||||
groups, restoration of strong points after alignment, raft layer indexing and
|
||||
structured slices. End-to-end tests slice a real object with Precise Seam
|
||||
tracking for the "had no effect" and whole-perimeter Blocked warnings, volume
|
||||
sorting of strong and weak groups, restoration of strong points after
|
||||
alignment, raft layer indexing and structured slices. End-to-end tests slice
|
||||
a real object with Precise Seam
|
||||
volumes and check the outer wall starts in the exported G-code: every strong
|
||||
mode under several seam positions and with a raft, Enforced and Blocked zones,
|
||||
a modifier with a hole, and the user warning.
|
||||
a perimeter blocked all round under every seam position, a modifier with a
|
||||
hole, and the user warning.
|
||||
- [Seam placer tests](../../tests/fff_print/test_seam_placer.cpp) cover
|
||||
enforced-patch selection independent of the contour start, fully painted
|
||||
contours, duplicate removal, and `Print::apply()` synchronization through type
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user