Fix arachne wall ordering (#7959)

* Revert "SPE-1950: Optimization of computation complexity of perimeter ordering for Arachne generator."

This reverts commit 47ec9b9b06.

* Revert "SPE-1963: Improve ordering of perimeters with Arachne perimeter generator"

This reverts commit babb84c70a.
This commit is contained in:
Noisyfox
2025-01-22 09:58:34 +08:00
committed by GitHub
parent a3de7cf0bd
commit 2253ab304a
8 changed files with 756 additions and 901 deletions

View File

@@ -782,4 +782,98 @@ bool WallToolPaths::removeEmptyToolPaths(std::vector<VariableWidthLines> &toolpa
return toolpaths.empty();
}
/*!
* Get the order constraints of the insets when printing walls per region / hole.
* Each returned pair consists of adjacent wall lines where the left has an inset_idx one lower than the right.
*
* Odd walls should always go after their enclosing wall polygons.
*
* \param outer_to_inner Whether the wall polygons with a lower inset_idx should go before those with a higher one.
*/
WallToolPaths::ExtrusionLineSet WallToolPaths::getRegionOrder(const std::vector<ExtrusionLine *> &input, const bool outer_to_inner)
{
ExtrusionLineSet order_requirements;
// We build a grid where we map toolpath vertex locations to toolpaths,
// so that we can easily find which two toolpaths are next to each other,
// which is the requirement for there to be an order constraint.
//
// We use a PointGrid rather than a LineGrid to save on computation time.
// In very rare cases two insets might lie next to each other without having neighboring vertices, e.g.
// \ .
// | / .
// | / .
// || .
// | \ .
// | \ .
// / .
// However, because of how Arachne works this will likely never be the case for two consecutive insets.
// On the other hand one could imagine that two consecutive insets of a very large circle
// could be simplify()ed such that the remaining vertices of the two insets don't align.
// In those cases the order requirement is not captured,
// which means that the PathOrderOptimizer *might* result in a violation of the user set path order.
// This problem is expected to be not so severe and happen very sparsely.
coord_t max_line_w = 0u;
for (const ExtrusionLine *line : input) // compute max_line_w
for (const ExtrusionJunction &junction : *line)
max_line_w = std::max(max_line_w, junction.w);
if (max_line_w == 0u)
return order_requirements;
struct LineLoc
{
ExtrusionJunction j;
const ExtrusionLine *line;
};
struct Locator
{
Point operator()(const LineLoc &elem) { return elem.j.p; }
};
// How much farther two verts may be apart due to corners.
// This distance must be smaller than 2, because otherwise
// we could create an order requirement between e.g.
// wall 2 of one region and wall 3 of another region,
// while another wall 3 of the first region would lie in between those two walls.
// However, higher values are better against the limitations of using a PointGrid rather than a LineGrid.
constexpr float diagonal_extension = 1.9f;
const auto searching_radius = coord_t(max_line_w * diagonal_extension);
using GridT = SparsePointGrid<LineLoc, Locator>;
GridT grid(searching_radius);
for (const ExtrusionLine *line : input)
for (const ExtrusionJunction &junction : *line) grid.insert(LineLoc{junction, line});
for (const std::pair<const SquareGrid::GridPoint, LineLoc> &pair : grid) {
const LineLoc &lineloc_here = pair.second;
const ExtrusionLine *here = lineloc_here.line;
Point loc_here = pair.second.j.p;
std::vector<LineLoc> nearby_verts = grid.getNearby(loc_here, searching_radius);
for (const LineLoc &lineloc_nearby : nearby_verts) {
const ExtrusionLine *nearby = lineloc_nearby.line;
if (nearby == here)
continue;
if (nearby->inset_idx == here->inset_idx)
continue;
if (nearby->inset_idx > here->inset_idx + 1)
continue; // not directly adjacent
if (here->inset_idx > nearby->inset_idx + 1)
continue; // not directly adjacent
if (!shorter_then(loc_here - lineloc_nearby.j.p, (lineloc_here.j.w + lineloc_nearby.j.w) / 2 * diagonal_extension))
continue; // points are too far away from each other
if (here->is_odd || nearby->is_odd) {
if (here->is_odd && !nearby->is_odd && nearby->inset_idx < here->inset_idx)
order_requirements.emplace(std::make_pair(nearby, here));
if (nearby->is_odd && !here->is_odd && here->inset_idx < nearby->inset_idx)
order_requirements.emplace(std::make_pair(here, nearby));
} else if ((nearby->inset_idx < here->inset_idx) == outer_to_inner) {
order_requirements.emplace(std::make_pair(nearby, here));
} else {
assert((nearby->inset_idx > here->inset_idx) == outer_to_inner);
order_requirements.emplace(std::make_pair(here, nearby));
}
}
}
return order_requirements;
}
} // namespace Slic3r::Arachne